A bill that make it a felony for pregnant women to use methamphetamine or illegal opiates is awaiting Senate review following its approval in the House on Tuesday.
But before it cleared the chamber on a vote of 46-13, House Bill 85 was amended to order Wyoming judges to sentence first-time offenders to probation and treatment rather than prison.Â
The stipulation was designed to address some legislators’ concerns that the prospect of a felony conviction would deter mothers from seeking treatment while pregnant. Â
Bill sponsor Rep. Ember Oakley, R-Riverton, introduced the amendment to her own bill on Monday during the House floor session and noted that such sentencing directions are not standard in state law. Â
“This is not done in any other offense in our statutes, so this would be groundbreaking,” she said. Â
Judges in Wyoming often have discretion in how to sentence convicted offenders. Â
“But hearing the concerns and trying to find the balance, I’ve crafted this amendment,” said Oakley. Â
The bill’s most vocal opponent, Rep, Karlee Provenza, D-Laramie, voted for the amendment along with the rest of the House, but voted against the bill every time it surfaced for a reading. Â
“(The bill is) still a bar between the woman and her physician,” said Provenza. “While I can appreciate the sentiment of this, I stand by what I said last week, which is the solution… is in health care statutes; is in making sure we have programs for them, not any form of punitive measures.”Â
The crime of meth use is a misdemeanor in Wyoming.Â
If HB 85 became law, using meth while pregnant would become a felony-level crime under Wyoming’s child endangerment laws.
Third ReadingÂ
The two delegates sparred again on Tuesday during the bill’s third and final reading in the House. Â
Provenza said she’d hope to see the issue addressed with treatment and counseling programs in the state’s publicly funded health systems instead of the criminal justice system. Â
Oakley said making more care available was a fine discussion for the body to have, “but what happens when (mothers) choose not to comply?”Â
“The answer is, I guess, never-ending expansion of government programs?” she asked rhetorically, then listed the government services and treatment opportunities that are available currently.Â
Even with all the programs, said Oakley, the prospect of a felony conviction would enable the state to “demand compliance and have that accountability” to ensure the “health and safety of many children as well as that mother.”