Casper Man Who Killed Alleged Child Molester Sues Over Toe Amputated In Prison

A Casper, Wyoming, man who killed his granddaughter’s alleged molester four years ago is suing a health care provider over his toe being amputated in prison. 

Olinza Headd, 56, filed a federal lawsuit Friday against Corizon Health Care, also called YesCare, and several doctors who have worked for it.

He accuses the doctors of putting the wrong salve on a wound and sometimes not re-dressing his wound — against the orders of a doctor who had seen him prior — causing his toe to be amputated.

Headd got to the Wyoming Medium Correctional Institution in Torrington on May 5, 2022. His toe was amputated more than a year later, Oct. 25, 2023, according to his civil lawsuit complaint.

YesCare is no longer the health care provider for the Wyoming Department of Corrections (DOC) as of June 30.

The company declined Wednesday to comment, saying it is barred by law from commenting on specific patient care and as a policy does not comment on pending litigation.

DOC also declined to comment but acknowledged that YesCare is no longer its designated health care provider.

Two Decades In Prison

Headd was charged in 2021 with second-degree murder, and later pleaded guilty to manslaughter, for killing Eugene Hogan III, who was 30, on Jan. 13, 2021.

He was a mental health counselor and a church deacon in Casper at the time.

Headd’s family members told him before the killing that Hogan, a live-in boyfriend to Headd’s daughter, had been molesting his granddaughter, according to court documents.

Headd snapped. He grabbed a gun, drove through a snowstorm to his daughter’s Casper apartment, confronted Hogan – who was lying in bed unarmed – and when Hogan allegedly gave a “nonchalant” answer about how he had only touched the girl, Headd shot him once.

Headd later told a judge that when Hogan was fumbling for a weapon, he shot him two more times, with a 9 mm firearm.

Headd’s daughter, with whom he seemed to have a troubled relationship, called police later that evening. She told police that Headd took her cellphones before the killing.

Headd would dispute this in court, saying his daughter wasn’t listening, and that he’d actually demanded to see his granddaughter’s cellphone.

The girl was given a cellphone in the first place because Headd and his wife were concerned that Hogan was physically abusing her, Headd told the court.

The judge sentenced Headd on April 21, 2022, to between 17 and 20 years in prison, nearing the maximum of 20 years for manslaughter.

That’s Why We Have Trials

At Headd’s sentencing hearing, Natrona County District Attorney Dan Itzen said the girl told a child forensic interviewer that she wasn’t touched sexually. She later told Itzen’s office that she was.

The girl’s reported waffling is exactly why Americans can’t go out and kill suspected criminals, but have rather to wait for legal processes to unfold, Itzen told the court, according to a transcript of the sentencing hearing.

“Judge, that’s why we have trials,” said Itzen. “That’s why we have 12 people sit right over here, and they deliver verdicts this side may not agree with, that side may not agree with. But as a society, that’s what we do. Right, wrong, or indifferent, he took that away from an individual, that (right) we all agree belongs to all of us.”

Itzen also questioned whether Headd merely “lost it,” and described some of his actions as suggestive of premeditation.

Headd wasn’t found until much later the night or the morning after the killing, walking down a Casper street. The murder weapon was never found.

“He shot an unarmed man for mere allegations, nothing more. And he did it in front of children,” added Itzen.

'Just Want Him Gone'

Marty Scott, Headd’s defense attorney at sentencing, said he disagreed with what Headd did but he urged the court to consider probation. Headd was considered a good candidate for probation, Scott added.

“I’m not excusing what he did. But I’ve gotten to know this man over these – over more than a year now and I know he regrets what he did,” said Scott. “But I also understand he is absolutely sincere when he tells us why he did what he did.”

When it was his turn to speak to the judge, Headd said he felt ashamed for letting harm come to his granddaughter.

He said his granddaughter said, “Grandpa, I just hate him. I just want him gone. He comes and he stands in my doorway and just stares at me. And – and he acts different when my mother is in the room than when she’s not.”

It hurt him “so deep,” Headd added. He was haunted by the prospect of “what she’s living under,” and he was ashamed for not picking up on the cues earlier and intervening with an “appropriate action.”  

Clair McFarland can be reached at clair@cowboystatedaily.com.